What A Crazy Day!
Riddle: Jake was talking to his friend Beth. Jake: Beth, I would like you to guess what I am thinking of. Beth: Alright. Beth got it right, and Jake did it again, but he thought of something else. Beth got it right again How did this happen. (Not based on personality or insider knowledge)
Answer: Jake is a schizophrenic who hallucinated beth, having her guess right every time.
Source: https://www.riddles.com/9512
